robocalls ยท 6 min read

Voicemail Drop TCPA Violations: Your Rights Explained

A voicemail drop is a technology that allows a sender to place a prerecorded audio message directly into your voicemail inbox without your phone ever ringing. The legality of this practice is a major focus of Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) litigation. Under the TCPA, you could be entitled to $500 per illegal call, and that amount can increase to $1,500 if the violation was knowing or willful. While marketers argue these "ringless voicemails" aren't technically calls, courts and the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) have increasingly disagreed. They often view a voicemail drop TCPA issue as functionally identical to a standard robocall. This means that if a company uses this technology for marketing without your prior express written consent, they are likely breaking the law and you may be owed compensation.

What Is a Voicemail Drop and How Does It Work?

A voicemail drop, often marketed to companies as a "ringless voicemail", is a method of communication that bypasses the traditional phone network connection to your handset. Instead of calling your number and letting it ring, the technology uses server to server communication to deposit a prerecorded audio file directly onto the carrier's voicemail server associated with your phone number. The result for you is a voicemail notification appearing on your phone without any corresponding missed call. Marketers favor this technology because they believe it is less intrusive and, more importantly, they hope it exists in a legal gray area not covered by the TCPA.

However, the intended purpose is the same as any robocall: to deliver a message to a large number of people simultaneously and cheaply. Senders use an autodialer system to upload a list of phone numbers and an audio file. The system then connects to the mobile carriers' voicemail platforms to deliver the message. Because it doesn't cause the consumer's phone to ring, companies have argued it is not a "call" and therefore exempt from the TCPA's strict consent requirements. As we will see, federal regulators and courts are largely unpersuaded by this technical argument, focusing instead on the impact on the consumer.

Do Voicemail Drops Violate the TCPA?

Yes, in many circumstances, voicemail drops do violate the TCPA. The central argument from senders is that since the phone never rings, they have not made a "call" to the consumer's device. This is a technical loophole they hoped would allow them to send unsolicited marketing messages without legal consequence. However, the FCC and numerous federal courts have rejected this reasoning. They have found that a voicemail drop is a "call" for the purposes of the TCPA, as it still results in a message being delivered to a service tied to the consumer's phone number.

In a 2017 ruling, the FCC stated that since ringless voicemail technology requires a call to a telephone number to leave a message in the voicemail box, it is subject to the same consumer protection rules as other calls. The consumer still has to use their device, their time, and potentially their data plan to retrieve and listen to the unwanted message. Therefore, a voicemail drop TCPA violation occurs under the same conditions as a standard robocall violation. The delivery of a prerecorded message to your cell phone without your consent is the core issue, not whether the device made a noise.

More importantly, these messages are almost always sent using technology that qualifies as an autodialer and contains a prerecorded message, two specific things the TCPA was written to regulate. Sending such messages for marketing purposes to a cell phone requires the recipient's prior express written consent. Without that consent, each voicemail drop is a potential violation of federal law. If you feel you have received these types of calls, you should explore if you can sue for robocalls and spam calls.

When Is a Voicemail Drop Illegal?

A voicemail drop is likely illegal if it meets the criteria for a TCPA violation. The key factor is consent. For telemarketing messages sent to a wireless number, the law requires "prior express written consent." This is a very high bar for marketers to meet. It means you must have agreed, in writing, to receive marketing calls or messages from a specific company through a clear and conspicuous disclosure.

Therefore, a voicemail drop is illegal if it is a marketing message sent to your cell phone and you did not provide that level of consent. This is true even if you have a prior business relationship with the company. Simply buying a product from a company in the past does not give them permission to send you autodialed marketing messages. The consent must be explicit and in writing for marketing communications.

Furthermore, if your number is on the National Do Not Call Registry, receiving a marketing voicemail drop provides an additional layer of protection and potential violation. Companies are required to scrub their calling lists against the DNC registry before launching campaigns. Ignoring the registry is often seen as a willful violation, which can significantly increase the potential damages you may be able to recover.

How Much Money Can You Get for Illegal Voicemail Drops?

The TCPA provides consumers with a powerful tool for enforcement: statutory damages. For each voicemail drop that violates the law, you may be entitled to recover $500. This amount is per violation, not per complaint. If a company left you five illegal voicemail drops, you could potentially recover $2,500. This is designed to make companies think twice before blasting out millions of unsolicited messages.

Moreover, if you can prove the company sent the voicemail drop willfully or knowingly, the damages can be tripled to $1,500 per violation. A willful violation can occur if a company knew about the TCPA's requirements and ignored them, or if they continued to contact you after you told them to stop. The possibility of these higher damages serves as a strong deterrent against flagrant violators. To learn more about how damages are calculated, you can review our guide on robocall damages amounts.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not create an attorney-client relationship. The outcome of any legal matter depends on the specific facts and circumstances of the case. However, the consistent fines levied against companies, as seen in our TCPA Settlement Tracker, show that these violations have very real financial consequences for businesses that break the law.

Real Examples of Potential TCPA Violations

Illegal voicemail drops can cover a wide range of topics, but they often sound professional and urgent to trick you into calling back. Here are a few common examples of what these prerecorded messages might sound like:

"Hi, this is David with Elite Health Advisors. We have some fantastic new health coverage plans available in your area with incredibly low premiums. We can get you locked in with a free quote today. Please give me a call back at your earliest convenience to review your options."

"This is a notification from ABC Solar regarding new government incentives for homeowners. You may be eligible for a full solar panel installation at no out-of-pocket cost. This is a limited-time program based on your zip code. Call us back immediately to see if your home qualifies."

"We've been trying to reach you. This is an important message from XYZ Lending about your pre-approved business funding offer. We have up to $250,000 available for you based on your business profile. Please press one or call our office to speak with a funding specialist right away."

How to Check Your Phone for Violations

Finding evidence of illegal voicemail drops requires a little bit of detective work on your own phone. Since there is no missed call log, your voicemail inbox is the primary source of evidence. Follow these concrete steps to identify potential violations and preserve evidence for a claim.

First, open your phone's voicemail application. Scroll through your list of voicemails, paying close attention to messages from numbers you do not recognize. Look for any voicemails that do not have a corresponding entry in your "missed calls" or "recent calls" list. This is the telltale sign of a voicemail drop.

Next, for each suspicious voicemail, take a screenshot. The screenshot should clearly capture the following information:

If your voicemail service provides a transcript, take a screenshot of that as well. After taking screenshots, listen to the message and do not delete it. If your phone allows you to save or export the audio file, do so and save it in a safe place. This audio file is the best possible evidence of a prerecorded message violation. Finally, start a log of this information to keep everything organized.

Check Your Phone Right Now

Finding evidence of TCPA violations might be easier than you think, and it can start with a simple search within your text messages, which often come from the same companies sending illegal voicemail drops.

Open your messages and search the word STOP.

This simple search will pull up every conversation where you tried to opt out of messages. Did the company honor your request, or did they keep texting you? Did you receive messages from companies you never contacted in the first place, forcing you to reply STOP? Each of those messages could be a violation worth $500 to $1,500. Gather screenshots of these conversations, including the ones that came before your STOP request.

Once you have screenshots of illegal texts and voicemails, you are ready to take the next step. Companies that ignore consent rules for one type of communication often ignore them for all types. Your evidence is the key to holding them accountable. When you are ready, you can Submit screenshots at SpamClaims.com.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are ringless voicemails legal?

That depends on the content and your consent. For informational or non-commercial messages, the rules are more lenient. However, for any telemarketing messages, ringless voicemails are generally illegal if sent to your cell phone without your prior express written consent. Marketers' arguments that they are not "calls" have been largely rejected by regulators and courts. The FCC considers them a type of call subject to the TCPA. If a company drops a promotional message in your voicemail without your explicit, written permission, they are likely breaking the law and you could be entitled to compensation.

How do I stop ringless voicemails?

Unfortunately, stopping ringless voicemails is difficult because they don't use a standard call connection that can be easily blocked by call-blocking apps. Because the message is deposited on the server side, your phone has no opportunity to intercept it. The most effective way to stop them is to make them unprofitable for the senders. Filing a TCPA claim creates a financial disincentive for companies to engage in this practice. You can also file complaints with the FCC and add your number to the National Do Not Call Registry, although these steps are less likely to stop determined spammers.

Is a prerecorded message left on voicemail a TCPA violation?

Yes, a prerecorded message left on a cell phone voicemail is a TCPA violation if it is a marketing call made without your prior express written consent. The TCPA was created specifically to address the nuisance of unsolicited calls using an autodialer or a prerecorded message. Whether that message is delivered via a live call that goes to voicemail or via a ringless voicemail drop does not change the fundamental nature of the violation. The key elements are the use of a regulated technology (autodialer or prerecorded voice) and the lack of proper consent. Companies that engage in this practice often pay significant sums, which you can see on the TCPA Settlement Tracker.

What counts as consent for a voicemail drop?

For a marketing voicemail drop to a cell phone to be legal, the sender needs your "prior express written consent." This is the highest standard of consent under the TCPA. It means you must have signed a written agreement that clearly and conspicuously states that you agree to receive automated or prerecorded marketing messages from that specific company at the number you provided. An electronic signature, like checking a box on a web form, can count as written consent, but the disclosure language must be unambiguous. Consent given for one purpose, like for transactional messages, does not transfer to marketing messages.

TLDR

Submit your spam screenshots for attorney review

This article is for informational purposes only and does not create an attorney-client relationship.